| Day | Date | Opponent | Location | TV | Outcome/Time |
| Sun | 11/23/2003 | Georgetown | Easton, Pa. | Lafayette Sports Network (RCN, WBPH) | L, 72-58 Recap | Box Score |
| Tue | 11/25/2003 | Sacred Heart | Fairfield, Conn. | | L, 92-59 Recap | Box Score | Gametracker |
| Sat | 11/29/2003 | St. Peter's | Jersey City, N.J. | | L, 73-50 Recap | Box Score |
| Tue | 12/02/2003 | Wagner | Staten Island, N.Y. | | L, 71-60 Recap | Box Score |
| Sat | 12/20/2003 | University of Denver Tournament vs. Denver | Denver, Colo. | | L, 76-69 (OT) Recap | Box Score |
| Sun | 12/21/2003 | University of Denver Tournament vs. Kansas/Texas Arlington | Denver, Colo. | | L, 81-59 Recap | Box Score |
| Mon | 12/29/2003 | Lafayette College Holiday Tournament vs. Cornell | Easton, Pa. | Lafayette Sports Network (RCN, WBPH) | L, 73-50 Recap | Box Score | Photo Gallery |
| Tue | 12/30/2003 | Lafayette College Holiday Tournament vs. Loyola | Easton, Pa. | Lafayette Sports Network (RCN, WBPH) | L, 78-51 Recap | Box Score | Photo Gallery |
| Sat | 01/03/2004 | Princeton | Princeton, N.J. | | L, 66-60 Recap | Box Score |
| Mon | 01/05/2004 | Quinnipiac | Easton, Pa. | | L, 78-62 Recap | Box Score | Gametracker |
| Wed | 01/07/2004 | Yale | Easton, Pa. | | L, 83-67 Recap | Box Score |
| Sat | 01/10/2004 | Colgate | Easton, Pa. | Lafayette Sports Network (RCN, WBPH) | L, 80-74 Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | Gametracker |
| Tue | 01/13/2004 | Army | Easton, Pa. | | L, 59-56 Recap | Box Score | Gametracker |
| Thu | 01/15/2004 | Harvard | Boston, Mass. | | L, 73-52 Recap | Box Score |
| Sat | 01/17/2004 | Holy Cross | Worcester, Mass. | Lafayette Sports Network (RCN only on 1/18/04 at 2:30 p.m.) | L, 71-65 Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio |
| Tue | 01/20/2004 | Pennsylvania | Philadelphia, Pa. | | L, 84-63 Recap | Box Score |
| Fri | 01/23/2004 | Lehigh | Easton, Pa. | Lafayette Sports Network (RCN, WBPH) | L, 64-53 Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio |
| Sun | 01/25/2004 | Bucknell | Easton, Pa. | Lafayette Sports Network (RCN, WBPH) | L, 67-48 Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio |
| Fri | 01/30/2004 | American | Washington, D.C. | | L, 72-54 Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio |
| Sun | 02/01/2004 | Navy | Annapolis, Md. | | L, 71-53 Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio |
| Sat | 02/07/2004 | Colgate | Hamilton, N.Y. | | L, 65-41 Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio |
| Wed | 02/11/2004 | Army | West Point, N.Y. | | L, 62-55 Recap | Box Score |
| Sat | 02/14/2004 | Holy Cross | Easton, Pa. (RCN Youth Day) | Lafayette Sports Network (RCN, WBPH) | L, 74-49 Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio |
| Fri | 02/20/2004 | Bucknell | Lewisburg, Pa. | | L, 81-63 Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio |
| Sun | 02/22/2004 | Lehigh | Bethlehem, Pa. | | L, 84-55 Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio |
| Thu | 02/26/2004 | Navy | Easton, Pa. | Lafayette Sports Network (RCN, WBPH) | L, 67-53 Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | Gametracker |
| Sat | 02/28/2004 | American | Easton, Pa. | Lafayette Sports Network (RCN, WBPH) | W, 64-61 Recap | Box Score | Photo Gallery | Archived Audio | Gametracker |
| Fri | 03/05/2004 | Colgate (Patriot League Tournament) | The Show Place Arena, Upper Marlboro, Md. | | L, 73-57 Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio |