| Season | Captain(s) |
| 1913-1914 | |
| 1914-1915 | Cornwell, Stevens |
| 1915-1916 | Ted Freeman |
| 1916-1917 | Ted Freeman |
| 1917-1918 | |
| 1920-1921 | H.F. Johnson |
| 1921-1922 | Guy Watton |
| 1922-1923 | Louis Hague |
| 1923-1924 | George Orr |
| 1924-1925 | M.H. Linnell |
| 1925-1926 | A.W. Whittlesey |
| 1926-1927 | Thane Cooley |
| 1927-1928 | H.C. Whittlesey |
| 1928-1929 | R.C. Potter |
| 1929-1930 | Geo. Garret |
| 1930-1931 | J.S. McAbee |
| 1931-1932 | L.L. Lowe |
| 1932-1933 | H.N. Snook |
| 1933-1934 | Irving Ritch |
| 1934-1935 | H.M. Scull |
| 1935-1936 | E.S. Jacoubs |
| 1936-1937 | Henry Eleniewski |
| 1937-1938 | James Tait |
| 1938-1939 | John Landis |
| 1939-1940 | J. Fitzpatrick |
| 1940-1941 | Jordayne Straughton |
| 1941-1942 | A. Ackroyd |
| 1942-1943 | Richard Ford |
| 1946-1947 | Eugehe Bourger |
| 1947-1948 | W. Lockett |
| 1948-1949 | H. McKinstry |
| 1949-1950 | D. West, J. Wynn |
| 1950-1951 | Bill Oaks, Bill Seaman |
| 1951-1952 | |
| 1952-1953 | |
| 1953-1954 | Robert Harrison |
| 1954-1955 | |
| 1955-1956 | Van Breda Kolff, Pew |
| 1956-1957 | Pete Reeves, Jim Murphy |
| 1957-1958 | Bill Wilcoxson |
| 1958-1959 | Bruce Forbes |
| 1959-1960 | Robert Kessler |
| 1960-1961 | R. Fox |
| 1961-1962 | Pete Knudsen |
| 1962-1963 | Herb Weiland |
| 1963-1964 | Vic Ferraris, Don West |
| 1964-1965 | Irv Jacobsen, Pete Stedman |
| 1965-1966 | |
| 1966-1967 | |
| 1967-1968 | |
| 1968-1969 | Bill Mandell |
| 1969-1970 | Geoff Caldwell, Steve Fanning |
| 1970-1971 | Bill Landis, Joe Lizz |
| 1971-1972 | Carl Goelz, Sal Vitale |
| 1972-1973 | Ron Cerny, John Ramm |
| 1973-1974 | Bruce Jones, Tom Goodwin |
| 1974-1975 | Bruce Jones, Tom Goodwin |
| 1975-1976 | Dil Lees, Jamie McLaughlin |
| 1976-1977 | Bryn Williams |
| 1977-1978 | Keith Forster, Tom Peddie |
| 1978-1979 | Terry Mulligan, Mark DeWalt |
| 1979-1980 | Doug Ciabotti |
| 1980-1981 | George Tiger |
| 1981-1982 | Nick Kapur, Mark Sidoti |
| 1982-1983 | Jim Benjamin, Nick Kapur |
| 1983-1984 | Jim Benjamin |
| 1984-1985 | David Fryman, Eric Kambour, Mark Neumann |
| 1985-1986 | Barry Buss, John D'Esposito, Jim Harari |
| 1986-1987 | Chris Anderson |
| 1987-1988 | Chris Anderson, Paul Bernieri |
| 1988-1989 | Tom Gillan, Paul Mignon |
| 1989-1990 | Brian O'Reilly, Peter Lugar, Tony Mazzei |
| 1990-1991 | Craig Kaisand, Tom Neale |
| 1991-1992 | Tom Neale |
| 1992-1993 | Jason Berry, Brian Rafferty |
| 1993-1994 | Jason Berry, Mike Gillespie, Timo Pape |
| 1994-1995 | Mark Dutkewych, Brad Pursel |
| 1995-1996 | Mark Dutkewych, Louis Joseph |
| 1996-1997 | Eric Rosenbloom |
| 1997-1998 | Guyan Randall, Jon Hanks |
| 1998-1999 | Dan Hughes, Pat Link, Renaldo Trancoso |
| 1999-2000 | Dan Hughes, Leidy Klotz, Tim Wenger |
| 2000-2001 | Keith Evans, Mike Gualtiere, Craig Schroeder |
| 2001-2002 | Keith Evans, Mike Saioni |
| 2002-2003 | Paulo Coelho, Adam Decker |
| 2003-2004 | Andrew Cottrell, Jamie Mullarkey, Tom Wajda |
| 2004-2005 | Nathan Jolly, Victor Krasij |
| 2005-2006 | Ryan McCaughey, Mike Tortora, Buster Wiand |
| 2006-2007 | Scott Backus, Luke Sullivan |
| 2007-2008 | Scott Hawkins, Anthony Sepe, Luke Sullivan |
| 2008-2009 | Chad Barbieri, Corey Dempsey, Steve Ference |
| 2009-2010 | | no captain selected
| 2010-2011 | Justin Kamine |
| 2011-2012 | Graham Heydt, Sean Peckham |
| 2012-2013 | Sean Peckham |
