| Season | Captain(s) |
| 1963 | Mel Mindich |
| 1964 | Fred Heller |
| 1965 | Howard Heller |
| 1966 | Bob Crampton |
| 1967 | |
| 1968 | John Spaeth, Jr. |
| 1969 | John Spaeth, Jr. |
| 1970 | Steve Hutnik |
| 1971 | Tom Roberts |
| 1972 | Jay Mottola |
| 1973 | Bill Frutchy, Fred Szarko |
| 1974 | Bill Scott |
| 1975 | Bob Stewart |
| 1976 | |
| 1977 | Jim Keosian |
| 1978 | Ron DeSantis, Pete Skalak |
| 1979 | Lew Knecht, Tom Flanagan |
| 1980 | Tom Flanagan, Lew Knecht |
| 1981 | Glenn Sparks, John Xanthopoulos |
| 1982 | Dave Kennedy, Tim Lucas |
| 1983 | Dave Kennedy, Tim Lucas |
| 1984 | Pat Donnelly, Doug Jones |
| 1985 | Bob Parsons |
| 1986 | Gregg Belardo |
| 1987 | Steve Senesi |
| 1988 | Dave Mooradian |
| 1989 | Chris Gillen, Henk Hartong |
| 1990 | |
| 1991 | John Armbruster |
| 1992 | Glenn Smith |
| 1993 | Matt Hoberman, Bob Main |
| 1994 | Charles Kacherski, David DeWolf, John Nalevanko |
| 1995 | David DeWolf, Sean Naughton, Robert Schenk |
| 1996 | Sean Naughton, Robert Schneck |
| 1997 | Robert Schneck |
| 1998 | Christopher Belfiore, Eric Starr |
| 1999 | Christopher Belfiore |
| 2000 | Frank Fazzinga, Ben Sena |
| 2001 | |
| 2002 | Brad Rock |
| 2003 | Brad Rock |
| 2004 | Brad Rock |
| 2005 | Garett Copp, Jeremiah O'Neill |
| 2006 | Tom Palmer |
| 2007 | Billy Simmermacher |
| 2008 | Brandon Mitchel |
| 2009 | Steven Melnic, Anoop Shah |
| 2010 | Reed Valutas |
| 2011 | Tyler Ostrovsky, Erik Adolfsson |
| 2012 | Carter Rufe, Rob Robertson |
| 2013 | Dave Kafafian |
