| Season | Captain(s) |
| 1882 | Henry Craven |
| 1883 | Theodore Welles |
| 1884 | Lewis Frey |
| 1885 | John Hamme |
| 1886 | Frederick Gutelius |
| 1887 | Frederick Paye |
| 1888 | Everet Camp |
| 1889 | Harry Mackey |
| 1890 | Joseph Fox |
| 1891 | Moncure March |
| 1892 | Gustave Voight |
| 1893 | Ernest Edwards |
| 1894 | Samuel Jordan |
| 1895 | Gideon Boericke |
| 1896 | George Waldbridge |
| 1897 | Charles Rinehart |
| 1898 | Charles Best |
| 1899 | Edward Bray |
| 1900 | John Chalmers |
| 1901 | Walter Bachman |
| 1902 | Harry Trout |
| 1903 | John Ernst |
| 1904 | Joseph Morrison |
| 1905 | Frank Newberry |
| 1906 | Erastus Doud |
| 1907 | Charles Ellicott |
| 1908 | George McCaa |
| 1909 | Arthur Blaicher |
| 1910 | Edwin Foresman |
| 1911 | William Dannehower |
| 1912 | Howard Benson |
| 1913 | William Wagenhurst |
| 1914 | Joseph Diamond |
| 1915 | John Luhr |
| 1916 | Paul Taylor |
| 1917 | Henry Lehr, Grant Scott |
| 1918 | Grant Scott |
| 1919 | John Weldon |
| 1920 | Joseph Lehecka |
| 1921 | Joseph Lehecka |
| 1922 | Frank Schwab |
| 1923 | Arthur Deibel |
| 1924 | Charles Berry |
| 1925 | Louis Gebhard |
| 1926 | Frank Kirkleski |
| 1927 | Harold Cothran, William Atkinson |
| 1928 | Richard Guest |
| 1929 | William Sherwood |
| 1930 | Raymond Woodfin |
| 1931 | Victor Reuter, Walter Vanderbush |
| 1932 | Adam Cirillo |
| 1933 | Jerry Miller |
| 1934 | Charles Nesi |
| 1935 | W.R. Cocke, Jr. |
| 1936 | Benjamin Snyder |
| 1937 | Edward Kanzler |
| 1938 | Harold Simmons, Nobert Weldon |
| 1939 | Hunter Jaggard |
| 1940 | George Moyer |
| 1941 | Joseph Laird, John McKenna |
| 1942 | Charles Nagle |
| 1943 | Walter Sergy |
| 1944 | Edward Podgorski |
| 1945 | Game Captains |
| 1946 | Ed Whiteman |
| 1947 | Tod Saylor |
| 1948 | Daniel Kovacs |
| 1949 | Gordon Schleer, Joseph Zahurack |
| 1950 | Jay Barclay, Joseph Diamnd |
| 1951 | Melvin Everingham, Gordon Patrizio |
| 1952 | Edward Greaves, Jack Herbruck |
| 1953 | Joseph O'Lenic |
| 1954 | Russell Hedden |
| 1955 | Jack Burcin, Bob Fyvie |
| 1956 | Robert Burcin, Jack Slotter |
| 1957 | Joseph Bozik, William Harrick |
| 1958 | Donald Dilly |
| 1959 | Donald Nikles |
| 1960 | Charles Bartos, Robert Howard |
| 1961 | Walter Doleschal, Peter Lehr |
| 1962 | Martin Shane |
| 1963 | John Brown, Richard Zanewicz |
| 1964 | Douglas Dill, George Hossenlopp |
| 1965 | Thomas Rosenberg, Joseph Smodish, Gabriel Washo |
| 1966 | Gary Marshall |
| 1967 | Robert Albus |
| 1968 | Richard Lettieri |
| 1969 | Gary Kolarik, Robert Zimmers |
| 1970 | Richard McKay |
| 1971 | |
| 1972 | Edward DiSalvo, Peter Tonks |
| 1973 | Thomas Kubler, James Nolan |
| 1974 | Adam Piergallini, Michael Slattery |
| 1975 | John Grimes, Mark Jones |
| 1976 | George O'Shaughnessy, Matt Walsh |
| 1977 | John Orrico, Thomas Padilla |
| 1978 | Jim Medes, Brian Musician |
| 1979 | Tim Gerhart, Rich Smith |
| 1980 | Steve MacCorkle, Ed Rogusky |
| 1981 | Steve Biale, Joe Skladany |
| 1982 | Bob Mahr, Ed Stahl |
| 1983 | Rich Doverspike, Frank Novak, Craig Williams |
| 1984 | Frank Corbo |
| 1985 | John Anderson, Ryan Priest |
| 1986 | Charles Brantley, Ryan Priest, Chris Thatcher |
| 1987 | Jim Johnson, Dave MacPhee |
| 1988 | Chris LaPietra, Andy Nygren |
| 1989 | Frank Baur, Dwayne Norris |
| 1990 | Art Bittel, Tim Costello |
| 1991 | Dave Levine, Tim Mocman |
| 1992 | Tom Kirchhoff, Kevin McManus |
| 1993 | Chris Flood, Pete Ohnegian, Dave Pyne, Mark Reardon |
| 1994 | Harrison Bailey, Erik Marsh |
| 1995 | Glenn Hunzinger, Gavin Morrissey, Jarrett Shine |
| 1996 | B.J. Gallis, Quincy Miller |
| 1997 | Dan Bengele, Craig Hansen, Todd Stahlnecker |
| 1998 | Angel Colon, Damian Wroblewski, Andy Zabinski |
| 1999 | John Fistner, Jim Goff, Chad Williamson |
| 2000 | Mike Levy, Phil Yarberough |
| 2001 | Jim Brown, Barret Diefendefer |
| 2002 | Chris Partridge, Chris Royle |
| 2003 | Wes Erbe, Marko Glavic, John-Frank Stubits, John Weyrauch |
| 2004 | Wes Erbe, Stephen Bono |
| 2005 | Maurice Bennet, David Nelson |
| 2006 | Marvin Snipes, Brad Maurer, Justin Stovall |
| 2007 | Marcel Quarterman, Kyle Sprenkle |
| 2008 | Andy Romans, Joe Russo |
