He served as the director of the Eastern Invitational Basketball Clinic where he handled logistical management for the nation's largest high school exposure camp while maintaining relationships with elite high school basketball and AAU coaches. In 2004, he was the director of Rebounds, a 28,000 square foot basketball facility where high school players can focus on development.
Toole was a four-year starter at the Division I level at Elon and Penn. He was the captain of two Ivy League championship teams for the Quakers and was a two-time All-Ivy League and Big 5 selection under then-head coach Fran Dunphy.
Toole resides on College Hill.