| Season | Captain(s) |
| 1925-1926 | Willam Cummins |
| 1926-1927 | R.C. Bew |
| 1927-1928 | T.C. Yates |
| 1928-1929 | Thaddeus Yates |
| 1929-1930 | A.S. Ridinger |
| 1930-1931 | J.P. Manley |
| 1931-1932 | Clifford Phoebus |
| 1932-1933 | Victor Lisks |
| 1933-1934 | James Bowman |
| 1934-1935 | James Quiney |
| 1935-1936 | Norman Syofflett |
| 1936-1937 | Thomas Hartranft |
| 1937-1938 | Thomas Hartranft |
| 1938-1939 | J.L. Hay |
| 1939-1940 | Stephen Wetmore |
| 1940-1941 | George Ryder |
| 1941-1942 | George Ryder |
| 1942-1943 | Richard Hartung |
| 1943-1944 | |
| 1944-1945 | |
| 1945-1946 | |
| 1946-1947 | |
| 1947-1948 | |
| 1948-1949 | |
| 1949-1950 | Jess Hawkins, Harry McAlpine |
| 1950-1951 | Lan |
| 1951-1952 | Hemeon, Olson |
| 1952-1953 | Phil Quinn |
| 1953-1954 | Larry Plummer |
| 1954-1955 | Ed Elbert, Angelos Paleologos |
| 1955-1956 | Ernest Seiter |
| 1956-1957 | David Detwiler, Roger Jacoby |
| 1957-1958 | David Detwiler |
| 1958-1959 | Henry Miller, Al Williams |
| 1959-1960 | Richard Segall, James Westkott |
| 1960-1961 | Martin Jezer, Jim Westkott |
| 1961-1962 | Ed Brick |
| 1962-1963 | Jeb Bell |
| 1963-1964 | Jack Whiteway |
| 1964-1965 | Jack Whiteway |
| 1965-1966 | Buz Callaghan, George Thieler |
| 1966-1967 | George Harper |
| 1967-1968 | Barry Simpson |
| 1968-1969 | Jeff Tinsman |
| 1969-1970 | Mike Weinstein |
| 1970-1971 | Scott Rodde |
| 1971-1972 | Norm Schwartz |
| 1972-1973 | Mike Fedoryshyn, Paul Galuszka |
| 1973-1974 | Joe Grimes |
| 1974-1975 | Mike D'Amico |
| 1975-1976 | Mark Van Buskirk |
| 1976-1977 | Tom Kuhns, Bob Williams |
| 1977-1978 | Matt Clark |
| 1978-1979 | Bob Sabin |
| 1979-1980 | Bill Deatly |
| 1980-1981 | Eric Bayer, Paul Hackenbrack |
| 1981-1982 | Tom Lawson, Bill McHeffey |
| 1982-1983 | Andy Hunter, Kurt Mayer, Jeff Miles |
| 1983-1984 | Kevin Hogan |
| 1984-1985 | Grant Doelp, Mark Pickering |
| 1985-1986 | Joe Morrissey, Anthony Swale |
| 1986-1987 | Mitch Bormack |
| 1987-1988 | Mitch Bormack, Steve Hladxzak, Tim White |
| 1988-1989 | |
| 1989-1990 | Dave Lehman, Don Sixey |
| 1990-1991 | Scott Epstein, Dan Rogers, Kevin Tyrrell |
| 1991-1992 | Scott Epstein, Dan Rogers, Kevin Tyrrell |
| 1992-1993 | Chuck Brunner, Dan Betjemann |
| 1993-1994 | Mark Andrews, Rick Ursone |
| 1994-1995 | Javier Fente, Steve Ripic |
| 1995-1996 | Ignacio Fente, Zdnek Hezky, Will Robb |
| 1996-1997 | Hashim Al-Mashat, Zdenek Hezky, Dennis MdKeever |
| 1997-1998 | |
| 1998-1999 | Evan Berer, Jonathan Levey, Greg Smith |
| 1999-2000 | Sean Hansen, Jason Thayer |
| 2000-2001 | Robbie Bateman, John Corrigan, Asoka Ratnayake, Mike Sanda |
| 2001-2002 | Lucas Kimmel, Asoka Ratnayake, Dan Sherry |
| 2002-2003 | Justin Gaudrea, Lucas Kimmel |
| 2003-2004 | Nate Delong, Kris Klein, John Veltri |
| 2004-2005 | Steve Connlain, Jakub Pritz, Colin Sinatro |
| 2005-2006 | Rob Gates, Matt Kemmerer, Mark Ranta, Greg VanVolkenburg |
| 2006-2007 | Ryder Pingry |
| 2007-2008 | Jaryd Freeman, J.B. Worster |
| 2008-2009 | Brian Cronise, Scott Robison and Seth Price |
| 2009-2010 | Steve Rubino, Aaron Lampley and John Jenkins |
| 2010-2011 | Steve Swaveley, Liam Carey and Brendan Lawson |
| 2011-2012 | Cory Schutz, Mike Black, Stephen McCormick and Tom Lombardo |
| 2012-2013 | Victor Giannini, James Kugel |
